Should I Break Up With My Boyfriend?


should I break up with my boyfriend

By Anita Chlipala, Divorced Girl Smiling Contributor, Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist specializing in dating and relationships

This reader is wondering, “Should I break up with my boyfriend?” Here is her email, along with my advice.

Dear Anita,

I’m in a 5-month relationship with my boyfriend. Things were great in the beginning but it’s been rocky the last couple of months. We’ve been arguing more and I don’t hear from him as often as I used to. I thought he was “The One” but now I’m not so sure. How do I know when to give up? Should I break up with him?

Dating is about taking the time to figure out if the person that you’re with is a good fit for you. Sometimes we believe so strongly that we have met our future partner – in the beginning of a relationship. But as time goes on, we can be plagued with doubts.

It takes time for patterns to develop, and at 5 months you’re around the point in your relationship where some of the infatuation fades and you can see your partner more realistically.

I commonly find that my clients stay in relationships longer than they should. A few questions you can answer to determine if you should stay or go:

1. Are you compromising your non-negotiables?

Do you find yourself rationalizing or justifying your boyfriend’s behaviors – or your own – that go against your non-negotiables? These can be things such as he wants to live in the suburbs but you don’t, or he doesn’t want to raise his children with a certain religion but you do. Whatever they are, if you find that you’re talking yourself out of your non-negotiables to keep your relationship, it’s not a good sign.

2. Are your needs being met?

If you’re considering breaking up, you’re unhappy to some degree. It’s difficult to feel fulfilled if your needs aren’t getting met. Think of what you find yourself complaining about or what brings you disappointment in your relationship – this can help you pinpoint your needs. For example, you want more communication but you’re not getting it – is this an important need for you?

3. Have you spoken up for what you want/need?

Some people think their partner should “just know” what they want. In the beginning of a relationship, you’re still learning about each other. It takes time to be so attuned to your partner that you can anticipate his needs, and 5 months may not be long enough for either of you to know what the other person wants. It’s better to speak up for what’s essential to you in a relationship.


Collaborative Law Institute of Illinois


4. Is there effort?

Relationships take work. They require conscious effort to not only consider your own needs, but also that of your partner’s. If your boyfriend isn’t demonstrating effort – or even if you find yourself without motivation – to make your relationship better, things probably won’t improve the longer you stay together.

5. Are you able to negotiate your differences?

Differences are inevitable. Are you and your boyfriend able to find win-win solutions to the things that you disagree on? Can you live with the differences if you can’t find mutually agreeable solutions? If not, you may have to find someone who is more naturally compatible with you.




Although there are no “one size fits all” answers, these questions can help guide you in making your decision of whether there is long-term success with your boyfriend.


should I break up with my boyfriend

Anita Chlipala is the author of First Comes Us: The Busy Couple’s Guide to Lasting Love. As a dating & relationship expert, she founded Relationship Reality 312 to teach singles and couples how to find and keep love. The one thing she might love more than love is her Chicago sports teams. To learn more, visit: This article was originally published on Anita’s blog.

Like this article? Check out: “3 Words For Those Who Have A Fear Of Dating”


Divorced Girl Directory


The most important word in selling your diamond ring




One Response to “Should I Break Up With My Boyfriend?”

  1. Lucile Louise

    This was what I needed to read when I was asking myself the very same question. Thank you so much for writing this. It means a lot to me and all the other girls out there asking themselves this very question.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Most Important Word in Selling your Diamond Ring
The Center for Divorce Recovery
6 Tips to Getting a Mortgage After a Divorce Divorce And Your House: 3 Real Estate Tips Divorced Girl Directory
Collaborative Law Institute of Illinois
Heal and Thrive with Fresh Start Fitness

Recent Posts

Divorced Girl Smiling advice video Divorced Girl Smiling advice video

Latest posts from our credentialed and qualified contributors

Lisa Kaplin Lisa Kaplin
Psy. D., CPC, Certified Life and Executive Coach and psychologist
The Benefits of Taking Ownership Of Your Emotions

The Benefits of Taking Ownership Of Your Emotions

Debra Alper Debra Alper
National Board Certified Health & Wellness Coach
Sometimes Life's Just Not Fair

Sometimes Life's Just Not Fair

Karen Malkin Karen Malkin
National Board Certified Health & Wellness Coach
How To Handle Sugar Cravings

How To Handle Sugar Cravings

Lisa Barr Lisa Barr
Award-winning author, former Editor-in-chief, The Jerusalem Post
My Mother's Day Gift To You: Let That Shit Go!

My Mother's Day Gift To You: Let That Shit Go!

Are You a Divorced Girl Smiling?