Is Second Marriage A Second Chance Or Huge Mistake?

is second marriage a second chance

By Jackie Pilossoph, Creator and Editor-in-chief, Divorced Girl Smiling site, podcast and app, Love Essentially columnist and author

Talk to any married person about second marriage and he or she will say something that makes me roll my eyes every time:”If I ever got divorced, I would never get married again.” Wow, does that bug me. Every married person says that, to which I reply every time, “Every married person says that,” and “How do you know? You don’t because you aren’t divorced.” The same people also say, “What’s the point of marriage unless you want kids?” What I wonder is, is second marriage a second chance? Maybe, maybe not.



The Case for Second Marriage being a mistake:


            I’m pretty sure the statistic for the divorce rate of second marriage is higher than 70%. And I can’t imagine second marriage is easy, especially if there are kids and ex’s in the picture. In other words, second marriage is not the Brady Bunch.


Vestor Capital


From what I have heard from countless couples who have done it, second marriage and blending families id complicated, and there are explosive situations happening almost on a daily basis.

The kids don’t want to be clumped together, one of the kids doesn’t like her dad’s new wife, the new wife gets hurt because one of the kids didn’t want her to come to her chorus concert, the ex-husband of the new wife calls and goes off on his ex-wife’s new husband for saying something he thought was inappropriate to his kid. The list is endless, and the drama causes lots of tension between the new couple, regardless of how much in love they are.


Divorced Girl Smiling Trusted Partners


I once had a woman tell me she has been married to her second husband for 25 years, and that although they have always been happy, there have been issues stemming from the kids and their ex’s throughout the marriage. An example: she told me that her husband’s son didn’t talk to her for a whole summer several years ago. The kid (who was 14 at the time) just decided he didn’t like her anymore and that was it. Another woman told me that the first year of her second marriage was “the hardest year of my life.”

So, why the heck would anyone want to be in a second marriage, especially after reading what I just wrote? Because I do think second marriage could be a second chance, and it could be absolutely wonderful.

Is second marriage a second chance? It sure could be! Here are 3 reasons:

  • If you liked marriage before, you will like it even more with the right person.

In my opinion there are two types of people: those who like being married and those who don’t. It doesn’t matter whether you are still married or divorced, you either liked being married or you decided you didn’t. Those who have never been married (let’s say 50 year old bachelors), they have chosen not to get married, probably because they just don’t want it.

So, if you liked being married, but were just married to the wrong person for you, half the battle is over, because at least you know you liked being married—living with someone, sharing a home, working together to raise kids, etc.


This is not real estate as usual.


2. Divorced people want a do-over!

Most divorced men and women have some pretty bad memories of their marriage. So, does that have to be it? Don’t I get a second chance? Those who want to get married again probably want the chance to make good memories, possibly learn from their mistakes and do it right this time.


3. Divorced people want that connection.

You can wear a ring, live in the same house and ACT like you are married, but for some people,  it isn’t the same as actually being married. There is a bond, a connection, a promise that comes with a marriage certificate. It’s not as easy to walk away. The commitment is concrete in a marriage.

There are no right or wrong answers, and I am not judging anyone who chooses not to get married after divorce. Some people are so hurt that they just won’t allow themselves to be put in that situation again. Some people are at peace with being alone or even just having a committed relationship without the ring and the papers.


As someone who has been divorced for several years, I still have a romantic, hopeful outlook when it comes to love, and I would absolutely love to be married again. But here is the key.


You can’t rush it or you end up marrying the wrong person. Wait for the one. The one that feels so right in your gut, that makes second marriage seem like a no-brainer, fully knowing all of the drama you will have to put up with.


It is definitely the situation that makes a second marriage right, and timing plays a big factor. But it truly is the person who makes it right.


Wait for him or her, and if that person doesn’t come, then second marriage wasn’t meant for you. And, don’t let anyone pressure you into second marriage—not the person you are dating, your family, or even yourself. In other words, don’t just get married again because you want to be married or you feel like “it’s time,” or you feel like you have to because you have been dating for 4 years. If you do that, you will most likely be looking at another divorce.


In closing, if you are a divorced person who wants to get married again, don’t let anyone take your dream away. Don’t listen to those who say, “Why do you need it?” Instead, listen to your heart and your gut. If second marriage feels right, I say let him or her fully have you and your heart and don’t hold back. Because, divorced people are allowed to have a fairytale ending, too.

Like this article? Check out 9 Signs of a Healthy Romantic Relationship


Buy novels by Jackie Pilossoph
Take the quiz to get recommendations Divorced Girl Smiling Trusted Partners

Sign up for the Divorced Girl Smiling newsletter to get weekly articles on divorce and dating.

Sign up
Listen to the Divorced Girl Smiling podcast! a weekly show about divorce and dating Download the Divorced Girl Smiling mobile app


The Center for Divorce Recovery
Take the 2-minute quiz to get recommendations
Divorced Girl Smiling welcome video
Jackie Pilossoph

Editor-in-chief: Jackie Pilossoph

Divorced Girl Smiling is here to empower, connect and inspire you. Jackie Pilossoph is the creator and Editor-In-Chief of Divorced Girl Smiling, the site, the podcast and the app. A former television journalist and newspaper features reporter, Pilossoph is also the author of four novels and the writer of her weekly relationship column, Love Essentially. Pilossoph holds a Masters degree in journalism and lives in Chicago with her two teenagers. The author of the novels, Divorced Girl Smiling and Free Gift With Purchase, Pilossoph also writes the weekly dating and relationships advice column, “Love Essentially”, published in the Chicago Tribune Pioneer Press and the Chicago Tribune online. Additionally, she is a Huffington Post contributor. Pilossoph holds a Masters degree in journalism from Boston University.

One Response to “Is Second Marriage A Second Chance Or Huge Mistake?”

  1. Nick

    I agree my father didn’t remarry till about 25 years after he and my mom split up, but he was the last person on Earth I thought would ever get married again lol all those years of preaching about how he never gonna marry again and then BAM. Also I think men are worst about remarriage than women, women are open to it more but are more selective as the years go by I wonder if that’s the real reason waiting for the right person after 9 years?


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.